An Extraordinary Story From Islamic History That Raises Some Very Uncomfortable Questions About How We Treat Animals Today.
I recently came across something quite extraordinary that I suspect most Muslims have never heard of.
Around 1,000 years ago, a group of Muslim philosophers wrote a story in which animals took humanity to court for enslaving, exploiting and mistreating them. The judge was the King of the Jinn, and the humans were required to explain precisely why they believed themselves entitled to dominate other creatures.
Yes, animals bringing a case against human beings and demanding justice!
Before anyone dismisses this as some modern vegan fantasy, this is an actual work of Islamic philosophical literature, known as The Case of the Animals versus Man Before the King of the Jinn, part of the epistles of the Ikhwan al-Safa, or Brethren of Purity.
I find this particularly fascinating because the questions these Muslim intellectuals raised a thousand years ago are arguably even more relevant today.
Who Were The Brethren Of Purity?
The Ikhwan al-Safa were a group of intellectuals associated with Basra around the tenth century. They produced 52 epistles covering subjects ranging from mathematics and astronomy to ethics, theology and the natural sciences.
Rather than merely discussing animal welfare, they devised an ingenious way to examine it. They allowed the animals to speak for themselves, present their grievances and challenge humanity’s claims of superiority.
The humans in the story capture animals and put them to work, treating them as property. The animals object and eventually take their complaints before the King of the Jinn.
Consider that for a moment. Muslim thinkers living approximately a millennium ago were prepared to place humanity’s treatment of animals under moral scrutiny, while many of us today cannot get beyond the fact that certain animals are permissible to eat.
But Allah Created Animals For Us!
Anyone who has discussed veganism with Muslims will be familiar with this argument. I have heard it countless times.
The general contention is that because Allah has permitted humans to benefit from animals, we are therefore entitled to use them as we please. Some seem to believe animals exist exclusively for our benefit, as though their entire purpose in creation is to serve our interests.
The human representatives in the medieval story make similar claims, appealing to their intelligence, accomplishments and elevated status. The animals respond by pointing to their own abilities, communities and roles in creation.
Being stronger or more intelligent than another creature does not automatically give us the moral right to abuse it. Surely our superior faculties should make us more responsible for the welfare of creatures who cannot defend themselves, not provide an excuse to exploit them.
Yet look at what we have done with our supposed superiority. We have developed enormous industries dedicated to breeding, confining and killing billions of sentient animals, often in conditions we would never tolerate for ourselves.
So Who Won The Case?
Interestingly enough, the judgment ultimately favors humanity on grounds of its distinctive spiritual potential. The Brethren of Purity were not writing a modern vegan manifesto, and it would be inaccurate to pretend otherwise.
But the importance of their work lies in the arguments they were willing to entertain. They recognized that animals had a case worth hearing and that human domination deserved serious examination.
I wonder how many of our contemporary religious discussions would benefit from that same willingness to examine uncomfortable questions instead of simply repeating the usual answers.
Imagine The Trial Taking Place Today
Suppose the animals were permitted another hearing, this time with evidence from the modern world.
They could show the court industrial farms where billions of creatures are specifically bred for consumption, many confined in conditions that prevent them from expressing their most basic natural behaviors. They could present evidence of habitat destruction, industrial fishing, pollution and the destruction of entire ecosystems.
They could show how we’ve turned the breeding, exploitation and killing of animals into enormous commercial enterprises, where the more animals processed, the greater the profit.
And they could ask humanity to explain why, in societies where adequate plant-based nutrition is available, so many of these animals must continue to suffer and die.
I have discussed the historical circumstances surrounding animal consumption in Why Did God Allow Killing Animals?. Not everyone throughout history, or even today, has the same access to food and alternatives. But those circumstances do not excuse the avoidable destruction carried out in the name of convenience, profit and habit.
Entire Species. Gone.
As disturbing as the modern animal industries are, humanity has another rather dreadful record that would surely feature prominently in this courtroom.
The passenger pigeon once numbered in the billions in North America. Hunting on an industrial scale and destruction of its habitat caused its population to collapse. The last known bird, Martha, died in 1914.
The great auk, a large flightless seabird, was relentlessly hunted for its meat, feathers and eggs. The last widely accepted breeding pair was killed in 1844.
Steller’s sea cow was described to European science in 1741 and hunted to extinction within approximately 27 years. The thylacine disappeared after persecution and other human pressures, with the last known captive animal dying in 1936.
And the Barbary lion, once found across North Africa, no longer survives as a wild population in its ancestral habitat.
These creatures existed long before our commercial interests arrived. We exterminated entire species because we wanted their meat, skins, feathers, land or simply considered them an inconvenience.
So I ask the human representatives standing before the judge: how exactly does the destruction of Allah’s creation demonstrate moral or spiritual superiority?
Clay Builds. Fire Destroys.
The Quran tells us that humanity was created from clay, while the jinn were created from fire (55:14–15).
I am not suggesting the following is a theological interpretation of these verses, but the symbolism presents a rather interesting comparison.
Clay can be shaped into homes and vessels. Uncontrolled fire consumes everything in its path.
Looking at the destruction we have inflicted upon the natural world, one could be forgiven for wondering which of these qualities humanity has chosen to embody.
We destroy forests, empty oceans, poison ecosystems and eliminate species. In many respects we have begun behaving like an uncontrolled fire, consuming whatever stands in our way.
And here we are, creatures made from clay, appearing before the judge to explain why we consider ourselves spiritually superior. Quite ironic, don’t you think?
Eating Meat Is Not A Sign Of Piety
I can already hear someone insisting that the Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) and his companions ate meat.
Yes, and so did his worst enemies!
Eating meat is not evidence of piety any more than eating bread or drinking water is. Diet is heavily influenced by geography, climate, available resources, society, customs and personal habits. It is not a divinely revealed menu.
The Prophet lived in seventh-century Arabia. His society consumed what was available to them, just as people in other regions developed diets suited to their own circumstances.
Islam regulated an existing practice; it did not invent eating animals, nor does the fact that the Prophet consumed certain foods mean every Muslim is religiously obliged to replicate his diet.
I’ve never disputed that Islam permits the consumption of certain animals. But there is an enormous difference between acknowledging permissibility and claiming the act of eating meat makes one more religious.
In fact, if we are going to measure our religious conduct against the Prophet’s example, perhaps we should pay considerably more attention to his compassion, restraint and concern for the vulnerable than to what happened to be on his plate.
Now Remove Humanity From The Equation
I’d like to present another argument before the judge.
Imagine humanity disappeared from the planet tomorrow. Not through violence or catastrophe; simply vanished.

Our roads, cities and industrial operations would eventually fall silent. Many forests would regenerate, polluted habitats would begin recovering, and countless wild animal populations would face considerably less pressure from hunting, habitat destruction and industrial activity.
Of course, the consequences would be complex. Some domesticated animals and species dependent upon human care would suffer. But much of the damage we currently inflict would cease.
Now imagine something different. Remove ants from the planet. Or bees.

Ants perform an extraordinary range of ecological functions, including soil turnover, nutrient cycling, seed dispersal and serving as food for other animals. Bees and other pollinators support the reproduction of countless flowering plants, including many crops upon which humans and other species depend.
Their disappearance would be catastrophic and the disruption to ecosystems and food systems would be enormous.
These are creatures many people dismiss as insignificant, yet their contributions to the natural world are indispensable.
So, Your Honor, I submit the following for your consideration: humanity claims to be the most intelligent and spiritually elevated species on this planet, yet the disappearance of many tiny creatures would devastate the ecosystems upon which we depend, while the disappearance of our own destructive industries would allow much of the natural world to recover.
What exactly have we done with our supposed superiority?
What Have We Done With Our Supposed Superiority?
The Quran tells us that animals and birds are communities like us (6:38). Yet we have treated many of these communities as disposable resources.
I find it rather unfortunate that animals have inhabited this planet for so much longer than humans, yet in a relatively brief period of human dominance, we’ve managed to drive so many of them into extinction.
As Muslims, we frequently speak about Allah’s mercy, the compassion of the Prophet (pbuh) and our responsibility as caretakers of this world. These are wonderful principles, but principles are only meaningful when reflected in our actions.
If our spiritual potential is what distinguishes us, then surely our conduct should demonstrate the highest standards of compassion, justice and responsibility.
I would encourage readers to explore this extraordinary medieval work for themselves and consider what the animals’ arguments might look like if the trial were held today.
Because if the animals were given another opportunity to present their case before the judge, I suspect they would have considerably more evidence against us than their predecessors did a thousand years ago.
And despite all our claims of progress, intelligence and spiritual advancement, I am not convinced humanity would have a better defense.
Historical Sources And Further Reading
The Case of the Animals versus Man Before the King of the Jinn, Epistle 22 of the Rasa’il Ikhwan al-Safa, translated by Lenn E. Goodman and Richard McGregor (2009).
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Ikhwan al-Safa · Quran 6:38 · Quran 55:14–15 · Smithsonian National Museum of Natural History · IUCN Red List
The historical courtroom account is paraphrased. Modern comparisons and the clay/fire analogy are the author’s reflections.

Join the Conversation